You’ve just left work and are going to meet some friends, or maybe to pick up the kids and take them to a soccer game. Uh-oh. Flat tire. You run out of gas. Your engine overheats. Your car dies at a stoplight. Now what?
I’m sure you’ve heard of both AAA and OnStar, but what’s the difference? And don’t you need a button integrated into your car to use OnStar? (Not anymore, you don’t.)
AAA (American Automobile Association) roadside assistance and OnStar are two of the most prominent players in the roadside assistance space, but which should you choose?
| Feature | AAA Roadside Assistance | OnStar Guardian App |
| Integration with Vehicles | No, operates independently of the vehicle | No, operates independently of the vehicle |
| Roadside Assistance | Towing (# varies by subscription), battery service, flat tire assistance, fuel delivery, lockout assistance | Towing (4 per year), tire changes, fuel delivery, lockout assistance |
| Automatic Crash Response | No | Yes |
| Emergency Services | Available with membership, accessible via phone call | Included in the app, accessible with a button press |
| Stolen Vehicle Assistance | No | Yes |
| Location Sharing | No | Included in the app, allowing users to share their location with trusted contacts |
| Membership Fees | Annual, fee for each additional user | Monthly/Annual, up to 7 family members included |
| Device Dependency | Not dependent on a specific device | Requires a compatible smartphone |
| Subscription Flexibility | No, membership plans are standard | Yes, users can choose subscription options |
| Vehicle Brand Limitation | Available to all vehicle brands | Not limited to a specific vehicle brand |
| Motorcycles | Yes, additional fee | Yes, included by default |
| Nationwide Service Network | Extensive network across the United States | Nationwide |
Conclusion
Both AAA roadside assistance and OnStar emergency subscription offer valuable services to motorists, but they cater to different needs and preferences. AAA’s longstanding reputation and extensive nationwide network that provides diverse membership benefits make it a reliable choice for those who prioritize traditional roadside assistance services and enjoy the added perks of membership.
OnStar’s Guardian app offers the ability to add up to 7 family members on a single user account, which could cost hundreds of dollars with AAA.
Don’t you need a button integrated into your car to use OnStar? Not anymore, you don’t.
Ultimately, the choice between AAA and OnStar depends on individual preferences, the size of your family, and the desired level of service. For those who prioritize a wide range of roadside assistance services and enjoy membership benefits, AAA may be the preferred option. Conversely, drivers with simpler needs or larger families may find OnStar to be a more suitable choice. Regardless, both services aim to provide peace of mind and assistance when it’s needed most on the open road.